HGG Community Forums

First , as ConfluenceStable says ; the only silly question is the one not asked.
Second why are you finding it difficult to breed to her ( your FreakyFriday) ?
I personnly find keeping ( and neutering ) as many as I can builds your show herd faster so you can make more HB's to buy more Barns and to support your breeding horse.
In general you need 2 or 3 ( most prefer 3 ) show horses for each breeding horse, and if you keep as many as you can ( esp if you are creating horses with points ) you ll be able to build stranger and faster :)

As long as you don't breed her to a stallion with frame again, you should be fine. A couple of my foundation stallions have frame, and I'm just careful not to give them any mares with frame (although one did slip through once, whoops!).

You don’t have to keep all of the horses you generate. You can sell high-pointed horses to get some $$ that in turn you can use to make more pointed horses, or save and buy more barn space.

As for whether to keep your freaky Friday mare or not, the question I’d ask is what are your breeding goals? Does her color help you in any way, or is she just a pain for you? If she doesn’t fit your breeding goals she would be worth more if you sold her than if you kept her as a show horse. And if you do sell her and realize it was a mistake that herd helper will come around again. Freaky Friday’s don’t fit my breeding goals so they never stay in my barn long.

Figuring out what you are trying to breed for will help you out the most because it gives you direction. Any goal would help for that matter because you can make decisions based on whether they help or hinder your current or long-term goals. :)

I have a thing for black and white splash tobiano horses (love that Vault of Stars HH!), and I am not sure the frame gene promotes that. My secondary color interests are silver, black, bay, and roan. Is that enough for someone to go on?
The horse in question has a PT rating of 9.9 and is a consistent performer, so I am not sure I want to spay. Is it common to spay or geld simply because a horse is inconsistent?

A Freaky Friday horse would be worth more to sell to someone else as a broodmare, than for you as a show horse. They are currently going for about 12-25k that's a pretty decent chunk of cash. As a show horse it would take her whole life to earn that for you.

Some rank special heard helpers have very little value beyond being a perfect create. All washed up, Color With a Really Long Name, Shades of Pale, to name a few. Rank special herd helpers value is determined by how many players value them, and how many players want those genes in their herd, and how badly they want those genes, and how rare the herd helper is. Freaky Fridays are one of the more popular RS they aren't the most popular, but they are sought after.